Theft offenses can be serious misdemeanors or felonies. These charges can have severe consequences on your life if you are convicted, leading to fines, imprisonment, and a criminal record. You should never take these cases lightly. If you have been charged with shoplifting, fraud, embezzlement, or other types of theft, a Painesville theft lawyer can help. The right lawyer can assess your case and fight for the ideal outcome, such as a dismissal or reduction of charges.

For over 15 years, Fortress Law Group, LLC has stood up and fought for the rights of our clients throughout Lake County. We understand how overwhelming and stressful criminal charges are to face. Even a seemingly minor offense can have a lot of immediate and collateral consequences on your employment, finances, and opportunities. We help you protect your future. Our Painesville criminal defense attorney has unique experience in the prosecution to better help you defend your rights.
Some of our notable case results include:
At our firm, we have experience with the Painesville Municipal Court and the Lake County Court of Common Pleas. Let us give you the support you need.
In all of Ohio in December 2023, there were over 5,000 other larceny offenses, nearly 2,800 shoplifting offenses, and over 800 cases of theft from a building.
There was a rate of 1,102 theft or larceny offenses in Lake County in 2023 per 100,000 people. There were 417 shoplifting offenses, 87 theft-from-building offenses, 72 cases of motor vehicle theft, and 495 cases of all other larceny offenses.
In Ohio, theft offenses include obtaining or having control over someone’s property or services, with the intent to deprive that person of their property or services, through:
Theft offenses in Ohio can include:
These offenses may be charged as misdemeanors, but many are charged as felonies, especially when the value of the stolen time or service is significant, or the victim of the crime is a protected person.
When there are no aggravating factors involved, theft is charged with the following penalties:
Protect Your Reputation and Future — Speak With a Defense Attorney Now
The evidence the state needs to prosecute someone for theft is proof beyond a reasonable doubt that the person knowingly obtained or had control over property or services of another with the intent to deprive the owner of that property or services through threat, deception, lack of consent, or other means. The prosecution may use eyewitness statements, surveillance or other CCTV footage, stolen property reports, receipts, and computer records to prove these elements.
The punishment for theft in Ohio relies on the value of the item or items stolen, the victim of the crime, or whether the stolen items were specific items like firearms or dangerous drugs. The lightest theft charge is a first-degree misdemeanor, which can be penalized by a fine of up to $1,000 and up to 180 days in jail. This punishment applies to theft of property or services valued under $1,000.
Theft offenses in Painesville, Ohio become a felony offense if the property or services stolen were valued at or over $1,000. There are also circumstances where theft is a felony even if the value of the stolen items is under this amount. This includes whether the victim of the crime is a protected person, like the elderly, a disabled adult, or an active-duty service member. It also includes whether the stolen property is an item like a firearm or motor vehicle.
You are more likely to win a petty theft case if you hire a theft lawyer to assess the ideal method of defense for your unique case. An attorney can review potential defenses, such as intoxication or a mistake, meaning you did not intend to commit the crime. Your defense lawyer can also argue misidentification by witnesses. An attorney may also be able to help you navigate and negotiate a plea deal that is reasonable and in your interests.
If you have been arrested for theft offenses, your next steps are vital for your future. Reach out to Fortress Law Group, LLC today to get a strong and knowledgeable defense and potentially mitigate the worst of the penalties against you.
★★★★★
“Attorney Matt Bangerter and his administrator Mia made it easy for me to provide the information they needed for my case through their online portal. Mia was always available to answer questions. Today, at court, Matt negotiated an incredibly positive outcome. I am pleased to recommend Fortress Law Group, LLC for your legal matters.” – Linda
★★★★★
“I can’t thank Matt enough for everything he did for me during my case. From the start he was honest knowledgeable and trustworthy. In court he was confident and professional, it was clear he knew exactly what he was doing. If you are in a tough spot and need someone to fight for you I highly recommend Fortress Law Group.” – Sarah
★★★★★
“Mr. Bangerter is a very professional lawyer. All questions were kept confidential and answered quickly. If needed would definitely use his services again.” – Lynn Hupp


Founder, Fortress Law Group, LLC
Matthew draws on his unique background as a former Assistant Prosecutor and his scientific expertise in molecular genetics to bring unparalleled precision and strategy to criminal defense in Northeast Ohio. Whether you’re facing misdemeanor charges, serious felony indictments, or federal prosecution, he builds defense strategies rooted in forensic evidence analysis, cutting-edge legal theory, and an unwavering commitment to protecting your constitutional rights and positioning you for the strongest outcome in court.